Quantcast The Red and Black
College Media Network

The Red and Black

Search the Archives

 

Fraternity may face sanctions by University

Abstract:
A University fraternity may face disciplinary action from the Office of Judicial Programs following a report that a woman was possibly raped at one of their parties, according to a newspaper report. The Athens Banner-Herald reported University police discovered possible violations of the University code of conduct as they talked to people who attended a Phi Gamma Delta party April 19....

  • Displaying 1 - 33 of 33

Frank J

posted 5/05/08 @ 4:09 PM EST

Frank J here.

What will it take for the University to finally take a hard stance on the numerous criminal activities conducted by the participants in the Greek system? How many pledges have to die? How many sexual assaults have to take place? How many underage drinking incidents have to occur? To say that the Greek system has run amok at UGA is an understatement of epic proportions. I have supported and applauded President Adams' tough stance on the Greek system but his discipline has waned in the recent years. Instead his tenure is now marked by numerous embarrassing incidents involving alcohol and Greeks.

Just like certain minorities are more inclined to engage in criminal activity or have lower SAT scores, Greek members are more prone to alcohol-related incidents and sexual assaults.

I challenge Pres. Adams to do the right thing and investigate this incident fully and maintain an open line of communication with the public. If the investigation discovers even a shred of wrong doing on the part of Phi Gamma Delta then the University should be banned from the campus for good.

FES

posted 5/05/08 @ 5:34 PM EST

Wow, Frank!? Which minorities are less intelligent and more prone to criminal activity? Prejudice oozes out of you.

And, you think the University should be banned from the campus--wouldn't that be a little preposterous.

Your anger seems to stem from the fact that you don't belong to any of the groups you abhor.

Originally posted by

Frank J

Frank J here.

What will it take for the University to finally take a hard stance on the numerous criminal activities conducted by the participants in the Greek system? How many pledges have to die? How many sexual assaults have to take place? How many underage drinking incidents have to occur? To say that the Greek system has run amok at UGA is an understatement of epic proportions. I have supported and applauded President Adams' tough stance on the Greek system but his discipline has waned in the recent years. Instead his tenure is now marked by numerous embarrassing incidents involving alcohol and Greeks.

Just like certain minorities are more inclined to engage in criminal activity or have lower SAT scores, Greek members are more prone to alcohol-related incidents and sexual assaults.

I challenge Pres. Adams to do the right thing and investigate this incident fully and maintain an open line of communication with the public. If the investigation discovers even a shred of wrong doing on the part of Phi Gamma Delta then the University should be banned from the campus for good.

UGA student

posted 5/06/08 @ 12:54 AM EST

Originally posted by

Frank J

Frank J here.

What will it take for the University to finally take a hard stance on the numerous criminal activities conducted by the participants in the Greek system? How many pledges have to die? How many sexual assaults have to take place? How many underage drinking incidents have to occur? To say that the Greek system has run amok at UGA is an understatement of epic proportions. I have supported and applauded President Adams' tough stance on the Greek system but his discipline has waned in the recent years. Instead his tenure is now marked by numerous embarrassing incidents involving alcohol and Greeks.

Just like certain minorities are more inclined to engage in criminal activity or have lower SAT scores, Greek members are more prone to alcohol-related incidents and sexual assaults.

I challenge Pres. Adams to do the right thing and investigate this incident fully and maintain an open line of communication with the public. If the investigation discovers even a shred of wrong doing on the part of Phi Gamma Delta then the University should be banned from the campus for good.


you are a giant douche bag. guess what, not just Greeks party. most people that go downtown and use fake id's to drink underage are not Greek. you are the reason Greeks have a bad reputation. You're too bitter about living in O-house for 5 years and your only friends being the ones you met and added on facebook or the ones with whom you protested at Tate about something that can never be changed. Grow up, get a life, and quit worrying about something you know nothing about. If you haven't been Greek, then don't judge.

Allison W.

posted 5/07/08 @ 1:29 PM EST

It's amazing to me what still seeps out of the mouths of people. You are the only ignorant person mentioned in your e-mail. OK, so you have an opinion about the alleged assault...state your opinion about THAT. Spare us your back-woods-redneck-inbred comments.I sense a bit of jealousy in your tone. Maybe if you had friends who invited you to greek parties you would have a better outlook on life. Let's just hope between now and your graduation you develop a life.

To the young lady who is the topic of the article, I hope wish you the best.
Originally posted by

Frank J

Frank J here.

What will it take for the University to finally take a hard stance on the numerous criminal activities conducted by the participants in the Greek system? How many pledges have to die? How many sexual assaults have to take place? How many underage drinking incidents have to occur? To say that the Greek system has run amok at UGA is an understatement of epic proportions. I have supported and applauded President Adams' tough stance on the Greek system but his discipline has waned in the recent years. Instead his tenure is now marked by numerous embarrassing incidents involving alcohol and Greeks.

Just like certain minorities are more inclined to engage in criminal activity or have lower SAT scores, Greek members are more prone to alcohol-related incidents and sexual assaults.

I challenge Pres. Adams to do the right thing and investigate this incident fully and maintain an open line of communication with the public. If the investigation discovers even a shred of wrong doing on the part of Phi Gamma Delta then the University should be banned from the campus for good.

O'Connor

posted 5/08/08 @ 12:29 AM EST

"Spare us your back-woods-redneck-inbred comments."
originally posted by Allison W.

I think maybe you should reconsider your style of attacking somebody. I'm what you might call a backwoods redneck, and I'm an English major with about a 3.7 GPA. While you condemn racist speech, you participate in classist speech. That seems a little contradictory.

Not a frat guy

posted 5/05/08 @ 6:28 PM EST

OK, how about a little self accountability. You drink to the point that you are possibly raped and don't remember... is it possible that nothing happened or that there was implied consent?

This should be a warning to anyone that goes to a party to make sure you go with friends that can look out after each other. What happened to her friends... what happened to self responsibility. If she was raped, absolutely prosecute; if she was drinking and underage, should she be prosecuted..

Sharon

posted 5/06/08 @ 4:51 PM EST

Originally posted by

Not a frat guy

OK, how about a little self accountability. You drink to the point that you are possibly raped and don't remember... is it possible that nothing happened or that there was implied consent?

This should be a warning to anyone that goes to a party to make sure you go with friends that can look out after each other. What happened to her friends... what happened to self responsibility. If she was raped, absolutely prosecute; if she was drinking and underage, should she be prosecuted..


From the article we don't know that she was drinking alcohol. She may have been drugged.

t

posted 5/14/08 @ 8:47 PM EST

Originally posted by

Not a frat guy

OK, how about a little self accountability. You drink to the point that you are possibly raped and don't remember... is it possible that nothing happened or that there was implied consent?

This should be a warning to anyone that goes to a party to make sure you go with friends that can look out after each other. What happened to her friends... what happened to self responsibility. If she was raped, absolutely prosecute; if she was drinking and underage, should she be prosecuted..


There is no such thing as "implied consent" if this young lady was uncounscious or impaired.

Alcohol is the #1 date rape drug used in this country. Think about that for a minute. The fraternity absolutely should have considered that -- it appears as though they provided alcohol to (many) minors.

If every young man and woman drinking underage in Athens were prosecuted the system would become clogged. Quit victim-blaming -- this young lady was doing the same thing as many other folks in this town on that same night. Unfortunately, she suffered painful consequences as a result.

The bottom line: take responsibility for your own safety. One night of craziness can result in life-long consequences (DUI, pregnancy, STD/HIV exposure, trauma -- physical and psychological) or even your death.

Rather than discredit the victim or the fraternity, take this as an opportunity to re-evaluate the safety of our community. We all live here, and no one wants to live in an unhealthy Athens.

-t

Alum

posted 5/05/08 @ 9:21 PM EST

UGA on trial. When the hockey team hazes their rookies, the "judicial" board ignores the wacky haircuts, and says they shouldn't make the newbies carry the bags of the veterans. When a picture of football rookies, with shaved heads or worse, is published, the "system" ignores it.

Now UGA has a fraternity discipline case. No evidence except a campus visitor at an open party, with two police present. The Fijis have no chance - they should contact their favorite realtor.

p

posted 5/06/08 @ 12:24 AM EST

If she cant remember anything then how on earth will police be able to identify a suspect (assuming an actual rape took place). Maybe she had consensual sex and just didn't remember it the next day. When you choose to get black out drunk things like this just might happen. We don't even know if a rape took place or not, yet UGA is going to "sanction" a frat for something that may or may not have occurred.

just a thought

posted 5/06/08 @ 1:27 PM EST

Calm down. If it comes out that there was actually a sexual assault at that party, I'm sure the fraternity will face sanctions for it. It hasn't yet been determined whether that did or did not happen. However, I get the feeling that more immediate disciplinary action may be due to what looks to be a violation of alcohol policies. In the final paragraph of the article, the student quoted said that she didn't see anyone checking IDs. That alone is plenty of reason for the frat to get in trouble.

p

posted 5/06/08 @ 1:37 PM EST

The frat hired 2 off duty Athens Clarke Police officers which is what they are required to do. One drunk underage girl saying she did see anyone checking ID's isnt enough to sanction a frat.

K

posted 5/06/08 @ 7:45 PM EST

Originally posted by

p

The frat hired 2 off duty Athens Clarke Police officers which is what they are required to do. One drunk underage girl saying she did see anyone checking ID's isnt enough to sanction a frat.


Actually, it could be.
You might want to read the Alcohol and Other Drugs Policy as well as the University's Code of Conduct. Not checking ID's at a organizational function where alcohol is being served IS a violation of the Alcohol and Other Drugs Policy and, therefore, the Code of Conduct.

N

posted 5/06/08 @ 4:50 PM EST

P,

You're assuming the anonymous girl that was quoted is A) underage and B) was drinking. It might be neither was the case. If one student saw alcohol violations occur, chances are other did, too. That very well may be enough to put the fraternity on some sort of probation.

Also, you should investigate federal law and find out what exactly constitutes rape. Sexual intercourse with a woman who is unable to consent is rape. A woman whose will is temporarily lost due to intoxication or unconsciousness arising from sleep or the use of alcohol or drugs cannot legally consent to sex.

Please don't get me wrong. I'm not saying anything of the sort happened at this fraternity. I don't pretend to know. But to assume "she had consensual sex and just didn't remember it the next day" is, well, wrong in theory and would still constitute rape.

James

posted 5/08/08 @ 12:36 AM EST

Investigate federal law? The federal government has absolutely nothing to do with state crimes like rape. The OCGA would most certainly control this issue.

Originally posted by

N

P,

You're assuming the anonymous girl that was quoted is A) underage and B) was drinking. It might be neither was the case. If one student saw alcohol violations occur, chances are other did, too. That very well may be enough to put the fraternity on some sort of probation.

Also, you should investigate federal law and find out what exactly constitutes rape. Sexual intercourse with a woman who is unable to consent is rape. A woman whose will is temporarily lost due to intoxication or unconsciousness arising from sleep or the use of alcohol or drugs cannot legally consent to sex.

Please don't get me wrong. I'm not saying anything of the sort happened at this fraternity. I don't pretend to know. But to assume "she had consensual sex and just didn't remember it the next day" is, well, wrong in theory and would still constitute rape.

Girl Alum, but not Greek

posted 5/06/08 @ 10:19 PM EST

This is an impossible situation, for both the girl and the fraternity. Who knows what happened? She doesn't.

I hear her friend says she was knee-walking drunk and denied alchohol by the Fijis.

Whether you hate fraternities or not, this fraternity has a GREAT reputation. If ONE of their members did something wrong, fry him, hang him, castrate him.

But to drag the reputation of a group of really good guys, real class gentleman (not your average group of fraternity men) through the mud reeks of Duke Lacrosse.

Did Fiji violate UGA alcohol policies? Yeah, probably. But is that really news? Underage drinking in Athens is hardly news. Whether at a fraternity house, a dorm or downtown.

But knowing some of these guys, I find it really difficult to believe that a girl was raped by one of these guys.

In fact, the Fijis I know would be horrified that such an action took place, and would toss the guy out on his head. I think they really value and care about their reputation as gentlemen.

If one bad apple went over the line, and if so, HE should be singled out, not the group.

t

posted 5/14/08 @ 9:00 PM EST

Originally posted by

Girl Alum, but not Greek

This is an impossible situation, for both the girl and the fraternity. Who knows what happened? She doesn't.

I hear her friend says she was knee-walking drunk and denied alchohol by the Fijis.

Whether you hate fraternities or not, this fraternity has a GREAT reputation. If ONE of their members did something wrong, fry him, hang him, castrate him.

But to drag the reputation of a group of really good guys, real class gentleman (not your average group of fraternity men) through the mud reeks of Duke Lacrosse.

Did Fiji violate UGA alcohol policies? Yeah, probably. But is that really news? Underage drinking in Athens is hardly news. Whether at a fraternity house, a dorm or downtown.

But knowing some of these guys, I find it really difficult to believe that a girl was raped by one of these guys.

In fact, the Fijis I know would be horrified that such an action took place, and would toss the guy out on his head. I think they really value and care about their reputation as gentlemen.

If one bad apple went over the line, and if so, HE should be singled out, not the group.



Unfortunately, a vast majority of rapes are "acquaintance rapes" -- where the victim knows the perpetrator. So, these aren't the scary men that grab you in a dark alley -- they're the men you already know. That's not to say your friends are rapists, just that it can be difficult to identify who will or won't rape, no matter how well you may think that you know them.

Frank J

posted 5/07/08 @ 1:44 PM EST

Frank J here.

I think many of you are missing the point. While many of you are focusing on issues such as if the girl was underage or not or if the sex was consensual or not, or if the fraternity hired UGA pigs, I mean police, to work at the function or not you all are missing the main point of allowing alcohol at fraternity sanctioned events. It just shouldn't be allowed. Here's a good example for you Greek monkeys out there than can't understand what I'm posting.

Alcohol and Greeks don't mix. It's like putting an unscratched lottery ticket down in front of a black and telling him he can't scratch it. Eventually, he's gonna have to scratch that itch, in this case, the lotto ticket. Eventually, if you give a Greek alcohol, he's going to get in a fight, raise a Confederate flag, toss out a racial slut at a passing minority, or rape someone.

It's a fact of life. It's as close to a sure thing as gravity. Sure, there are a few exceptions (like space) but not many.

J

posted 5/07/08 @ 5:14 PM EST

Originally posted by

Frank J

Frank J here.

I think many of you are missing the point. While many of you are focusing on issues such as if the girl was underage or not or if the sex was consensual or not, or if the fraternity hired UGA pigs, I mean police, to work at the function or not you all are missing the main point of allowing alcohol at fraternity sanctioned events. It just shouldn't be allowed. Here's a good example for you Greek monkeys out there than can't understand what I'm posting.

Alcohol and Greeks don't mix. It's like putting an unscratched lottery ticket down in front of a black and telling him he can't scratch it. Eventually, he's gonna have to scratch that itch, in this case, the lotto ticket. Eventually, if you give a Greek alcohol, he's going to get in a fight, raise a Confederate flag, toss out a racial slut at a passing minority, or rape someone.

It's a fact of life. It's as close to a sure thing as gravity. Sure, there are a few exceptions (like space) but not many.



Well Frank J, I think YOU are missing the point. I am not Greek, but I feel the need to defend them after what you just said. That comparison of alcohol:greeks::lotto tickets:blacks is absolutely wrong. That's the most absurd, discriminatory, and racist thing I've ever heard come out of a person's mouth. You should be ashamed of yourself for making a comparison like that. All of those things you said could happen due to alcohol consumption can just as easily happen without it and those acts can just as easily be committed by non-greeks. Let's look at the ratio of greeks to non-greeks on this campus. I'm pretty sure there are about 4x as many non-greeks that can commit such acts.

Jed Clampett

posted 5/08/08 @ 10:27 AM EST

Greeks are stupid. The whole concept of this is just pretty gay and sad. Name some good things that greeks do and actual positives of the system other than social activities, because you have to pay for your douchebag friends. Grow up. High School is over. There shouldn't be an "in" crowd at college, especially if you have to pay for it. Who gives a shit?

Jessica

posted 5/08/08 @ 6:21 PM EST

First of all, are you mad because your not in this so called "in crowd?" or are you still bitter because you weren't in highschool either? Agreed, in crowd stuff is stupid. Its a community, not an incrowd, unless others say it is and if you dont want it to be, don't call it that. The Greek system does a world of good. Philanthropies and community service. If you were more educated in what you are talking about, you would know this. On average, the Greek system sororities have higher GPA's than non greeks. Get your facts straight before you attack a system next. I am not all about partying but more involved in the greek community activities and it is a great way to network.

Originally posted by

Jed Clampett

Greeks are stupid. The whole concept of this is just pretty gay and sad. Name some good things that greeks do and actual positives of the system other than social activities, because you have to pay for your douchebag friends. Grow up. High School is over. There shouldn't be an "in" crowd at college, especially if you have to pay for it. Who gives a shit?

Ugh!

posted 5/08/08 @ 10:42 AM EST

Please, please, everyone, just ignore Frank J. He's a troll (probably the Bobster, in fact) who gets his jollies by provoking people to get a rise out of them. If we pretend he doesn't exist, he'll just go away.

Former Greek Pres

posted 5/08/08 @ 11:32 AM EST

The Greek system at UGA is not to blame here. Frank J has a history of going after the Greeks. I played on the club lacrosse team at UGA and was hazed worse there than I was at my fraternity. There are no more underage students drinking at fraternity parties than there are downtown. If something needs to be done, it needs to be done campus wide.

The real problem here revolves around 2 University rules FIJI failed to follow involving the party. Every fraternity pres and Risk management officer knows that "open" parties are clearly against greek life rules. The same applies to central sources of alcohol. If they had followed these two policies this event would have likely never taken place. I have been to plenty of great parties at the best houses on campus who have no problem following these rules.

The alcohol problem at UGA is not a Greek issue, it's a UGA issue. Anyone who says otherwise is quite unrealistic.

Jed Clampett

posted 5/08/08 @ 9:53 PM EST

Greeks have higher GPAs because they are more likely to collaborate and cheat. I've seen it first hand. And yes.... it is in-crowd bullshit, and I will call it that until it changes it ways.

K

posted 5/10/08 @ 4:48 PM EST

Everyone is just blaming the greek system just as a scape goat to not blame themselves. Maybe she was raped but if you get so drunk and make stupid mistakes you didn't realize all someone would do is look for someone else to blame because everyone knows that it wasn't their own fault. The greek system does a lot of good for a philanthropy and shouldn't be the blame of UGA's fault. If she can't remember what happened, who is not to say she gave consent?

Anonymous

posted 5/10/08 @ 11:42 PM EST

At any party anywhere, Greek or non-Greek, there is going to be drinking by people too young or too drunk to be drinking. It happens. It's college. And those too young have fake IDs, which aren't going to be checked any harder than they are downtown. There are always going to be situations like this in Athens, no matter what measures are taken to contain them. The problem here is that a girl made a bad decision by drinking too much(according to what we know in the public) and chose to put the blame on FIJI for the consequences. What if it had happened at a friend's party? Basically, everyone in Athens has become quick to jump at the chance that a Greek is at fault for a problem. Sometimes they are, sometimes they aren't. Same goes for SPIA members. Same goes for Habitat for Humanity. Same goes for just about any organization at UGA. PEOPLE MESS UP. Don't attack an organization unless you plan to attack ALL organizations. How about we just shut down student affairs? Cancel extracurricular activities? Let's ban tailgating. See? These are all understandable but not well-thought out accusations and it all just needs to stop.

...

posted 5/11/08 @ 8:49 PM EST

First off, to K: it's already been established that you cannot legally give consent if you are intoxicated. Ergo, if she was so intoxicated that she can't remember the incident, she could not legally give consent, and it's rape. If it happened. Nobody knows for sure yet.

To "Anonymous": let's back up a minute and look at the facts. Nowhere in this article can I find anything that says the girl is accusing FIJI itself of doing anything. It just happened at their party. Another female student who attended the party made all those comments about the drinking. The frat may or may not face sanctions if anything is proven as far as underage drinking is concerned. But if people are accusing the fraternity on this message board, that's a different matter.

I'm still kind of trying to make up my mind about all this, but here's what I'm wondering: do you really think *all* organizations habitually make this kind of "mistake"? I won't deny that other individuals and organizations besides fraternities have parties, but where else do you have precisely that combination of youth and debauchery, one that fosters a culture that's responsible for 55% of gang rapes on campus (40% are done by sports teams, so I guess that's another issue). If, according to UGA's Undergrad Admissions site, only 18% of UGA students are Greek, and it follows that an even smaller number of those students are male, then what do you have but a relatively small group that's responsible for a disproportionate number of sexual assaults?

All the stars are aligned at a frat party: the vat of hunch punch, the unequal numbers of guys and girls, the brotherly competition for women, the empty rooms upstairs... Do you think that kind of setup is really the case at tailgates or Habitat for Humanity functions (not sure why you cited that organization...)? As for SPIA, it does sound like they had a (as in, one) professor who misbehaved. How many times before this year was sexual conduct alleged in their department? And how many times in the last few years have Greeks been accused or convicted of rape? I mean, do the math. That's not attacking the Greeks; those are the real numbers.

Do I think all Greek organizations should be disbanded? Of course not. But I think UGA should be concerned about the kind of environment that's fostered at frat parties in particular, and that it should consider the university guidelines about drinking and act according to the letter of that law in order to strongly discourage the kinds of problems that inevitably happen around alcohol-fueled events. Who else on campus besides Greeks has a weekly debauch on that scale? There's a big ol' bulls-eye right on top of all those lovely mansions, and maybe for good reason.

* Got my statistics from here, for what they're worth: www.uga.edu/ovp/pdf/sexual_violence_factsheet.pdf

Scott

posted 5/12/08 @ 5:48 PM EST

Frank J,

First off, you've got to be one of the most ignorant people on here. Secondly, why would you throw a racial slut at someone? Even if she was only 100 lbs, you still might hurt your back. Proofreading can help make it look like you're only a racist, instead of an stupid racist.

SW

posted 5/12/08 @ 8:12 PM EST

Proofreading is good, especially if you are "an stupid racist" instead of "a" stupid racist.




Originally posted by

Scott

Frank J,

First off, you've got to be one of the most ignorant people on here. Secondly, why would you throw a racial slut at someone? Even if she was only 100 lbs, you still might hurt your back. Proofreading can help make it look like you're only a racist, instead of an stupid racist.

...

posted 5/12/08 @ 8:48 PM EST

Okay, SW, so which is worse: bad proofreading or rampant racism? Hmmm. Dilemma. Glad you at least have your priorities in order.

SW

posted 5/13/08 @ 6:33 PM EST

You are in college, therefore should know proper grammar. Racism, that's a different story. College can not cure that.



Originally posted by

...

Okay, SW, so which is worse: bad proofreading or rampant racism? Hmmm. Dilemma. Glad you at least have your priorities in order.

...

posted 5/13/08 @ 9:35 PM EST

You're right: it cannot. "Cannot" is one word, by the way.

I reiterate: is it possible that you're straining out a gnat and swallowing a camel? I'm a college English teacher who's quite taken with good grammar, but even I think it's more productive to have a real discussion about what racism means than it is to pick at someone's errant typing error. I'd rather converse with someone with terrible grammar skills who doesn't stereotype people than with a veritable Harbrace who still uses the subjunctive impeccably.

But then, what do I know?

Beer!

posted 5/14/08 @ 2:35 AM EST

So she might have been wasted and couldn't legally give consent, but what if the guy was wasted too. What if it was two drunken people consenting to sex...?
  • Displaying 1 - 33 of 33

Post Your Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

 

 

Advertisement

Poll

Hmm, what to make of Kentucky vs. Georgia:
Submit Vote

View Results



Advertisement